My Ex-Partner is Trying to Take Me To Court Again – What Can I Do?

Exasperated young business woman sitting at a table with laptop and coffee, head in her hands

My Ex-Partner is Trying to Take Me To Court Again – What Can I Do?

Litigation can be a very difficult experience.  It can be expensive, time-consuming and exhausting.

So what can you do if you have already been to Court, only for your ex-partner to threaten to take you back to Court again? Is there anything you can do to stop them?

This article explores 2 of your possible options:-

  1. Vexatious proceedings orders; and
  2. Harmful proceedings orders.

There are other things parties need to be aware of before bringing a matter back to Court – for example, you may wish to consider our article Can I Change My Final Parenting Orders? How Final Are Final Parenting Orders? Changes to the Family Law Act 2024.

Vexatious Proceedings

It has been long-recognised that the Court can dismiss an Application if it is “vexatious”.

Under section 102QB of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth), the Court is empowered to make certain Orders, if the Court is satisfied that a person has frequently instituted or conducted vexatious proceedings. [1]

A vexatious proceeding includes:- [2]

  • a proceeding that is an abuse of the process of a court or tribunal;
  • a proceeding instituted in a court or tribunal to harass or annoy, to cause delay or detriment, or for another wrongful purpose;
  • a proceeding instituted or pursued in a court or tribunal without reasonable ground; and/or
  • a proceeding conducted in a court or tribunal in a way so as to harass or annoy, cause delay or detriment, or achieve another wrongful purpose.

If the Court is satisfied that a person has frequently instituted vexatious proceedings, the Court may make an Order:-

  • staying or dismissing any proceedings in the court already instituted by the person; [3] and/or
  • prohibiting the person from instituting proceedings. [4]

So, if your ex-partner is filing vexatious proceedings, the Court has the power to put a stop to it. However, your ex-partner needs to be “frequently” doing so.

But what if your ex-partner is bringing proceedings which may not be “vexatious”, but which may still be harmful to you and your family?

Harmful Proceedings – A Brief History

This issue arose in the matter of Marsden & Winch. [5]

In that case, the parties had been involved in litigation for nearly a decade. The father had brought numerous Applications, many of which were unsuccessful but none of which had been dismissed previously as vexatious. This was because the father had not repeatedly brought the same type of Application – each Applicant was different.

The Full Court identified that both the mother and the subject daughter had suffered trauma and psychological harm as a result of the proceedings, but nevertheless concluded that harm did not fall within the list of categories that would empower the Court to declare that the Application was vexatious.

Harmful Proceedings Orders – A New Solution

As a result of the issues identified in Marsden & Winch and similar cases, the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) was amended to introduce a new section, s 102QAC, which now empowers the Court to make “harmful proceedings orders”.

To make such an Order, the Court must be satisfied that there are reasonable grounds to believe that:-

  • One party would suffer harm if the other party instituted further proceedings; [6] or
  • A child who is the subject of the proceedings could suffer harm if a party instituted further proceedings. [7]

“Harm” is defined to include – but is not limited to – psychological harm or oppression, major mental distress, a detrimental effect on a party’s capacity to care for a child and/or financial harm. [8]

If the Court is satisfied that those grounds exist, the Court may dismiss proceedings, and may make an Order prohibiting a party from instituting proceeding, without leave of the Court. 

Power to be Exercised Sparingly  

It should be noted, however, that the Court is reluctant to refuse to allow a party to have an Application heard without good reason.

In Lindon v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) His Honour Kirby J said: [9]

It is a serious matter to deprive a person of access to the courts of law for it is there that the rule of law is upheld, including against Government and other powerful interests. This is why relief… is rarely and sparingly provided…

This means that litigants will need to have compelling reasons before the Court will make such an Order.

Key Take-Aways

  1. If your ex-partner tries to take you back to Court after you have received Final Orders, the Court may have the power to declare the Application vexatious or harmful depending on the circumstances;
  2. Vexatious proceedings include proceedings which are frequently instituted to harass or annoy, to cause delay or detriment, or for another wrongful purpose;
  3. Harmful proceedings include proceedings which may reasonably cause a party or child to experience harm including psychological harm or oppression, major mental distress, a detrimental effect on a party’s capacity to care for a child and/or financial harm;
  4. The Court is reluctant to refuse to allow a party to have their Application heard without very good reason however; and
  5. If your ex-partner is threatening to take you back to Court after you have received Final Orders, you should always seek legal advice to navigate the complexities of Family Law system, and to ensure that you are receiving advice that is tailored to your unique family circumstances.

References

[1] Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) s 102QB(1)(a).

[2] Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Act 2021 (Cth).

[3]  Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) s 102QB(2)(a).

[4] Ibid s 102QB(2)(b).

[5] [2013] FamCAFC 177.

[6] Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) s 102QAC(1)(a).

[7] Ibid s 102QAC(1)(b).

[8] Ibid s 102QAC(2).

[9] [1996] HCA 14 at [14].

Going through a separation?

Our free Separation Guide explains the first steps after separation in plain English.

To contact our team, email info@clarkmoore.com.au or call 07 3167 6200

To contact our team, email info@clarkmoore.com.au or call 07 3167 6200

Disclaimer: The information provided in this blog is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. While we strive to ensure the accuracy and reliability of the information, it is subject to change and may not reflect the latest legal developments. Readers should not act upon this information without seeking professional legal advice specific to their situation. Clark Moore Legal disclaims any liability for actions taken based on the content of this blog. For tailored legal advice, please contact us directly.

Share Now:

Categories

Recent Articles in this Category